 
          104
        
        
          
            Technical article assessment criteria sheet
          
        
        
          Assessment
        
        
          criteria
        
        
          3 points /
        
        
          Excellent
        
        
          2 points / good 1 point /
        
        
          needs work
        
        
          0 point /poor
        
        
          
            Attitude
          
        
        
          Demonstrates
        
        
          strong
        
        
          enthusiasm
        
        
          about
        
        
          the
        
        
          researched
        
        
          subject.
        
        
          Demonstrates
        
        
          enthusiasm
        
        
          about
        
        
          the
        
        
          researched
        
        
          subject.
        
        
          Demonstrates
        
        
          little
        
        
          enthusiasm
        
        
          about
        
        
          the
        
        
          researched
        
        
          subject.
        
        
          Shows
        
        
          no
        
        
          interest in the
        
        
          researched
        
        
          subject.
        
        
          
            Content
          
        
        
          The
        
        
          researched
        
        
          subject
        
        
          is
        
        
          clearly stated.
        
        
          Th
        
        
          The
        
        
          researched
        
        
          subject
        
        
          is
        
        
          defined.
        
        
          The
        
        
          researched
        
        
          subject
        
        
          is
        
        
          stated, but not
        
        
          clearly.
        
        
          The researched
        
        
          subject is not
        
        
          stated.
        
        
          Provides
        
        
          theory
        
        
          including
        
        
          a
        
        
          variety
        
        
          of
        
        
          laws,
        
        
          formulae,
        
        
          facts, statistics
        
        
          etc.
        
        
          Provides
        
        
          theory
        
        
          including
        
        
          some
        
        
          laws,
        
        
          formulae,
        
        
          facts, statistics
        
        
          etc.
        
        
          Provides
        
        
          theory
        
        
          including a
        
        
          few
        
        
          laws,
        
        
          formulae,
        
        
          facts,
        
        
          statistics etc.
        
        
          Provides
        
        
          no
        
        
          theory.
        
        
          
            Creativity
          
        
        
          Ideas
        
        
          are
        
        
          creative and
        
        
          inventive.
        
        
          Work shows
        
        
          new ideas and
        
        
          insights.
        
        
          Work shows
        
        
          few ideas and
        
        
          insights.
        
        
          Work shows no
        
        
          ideas
        
        
          and
        
        
          insights.
        
        
          
            Language
          
        
        
          Uses a variety
        
        
          of vocabulary
        
        
          and
        
        
          expression
        
        
          (including
        
        
          professional
        
        
          thesaurus).
        
        
          The
        
        
          vocabulary
        
        
          corresponds to
        
        
          the task.
        
        
          Uses a number
        
        
          of vocabulary
        
        
          and expression
        
        
          (including
        
        
          professional
        
        
          thesaurus).
        
        
          The
        
        
          vocabulary
        
        
          and grammar
        
        
          mostly
        
        
          correspond to
        
        
          the task.
        
        
          Uses
        
        
          only
        
        
          basic
        
        
          vocabulary
        
        
          and
        
        
          expression.
        
        
          The
        
        
          vocabulary
        
        
          sometimes
        
        
          corresponds
        
        
          to the task.
        
        
          The
        
        
          comprehension
        
        
          of the report is
        
        
          hampered
        
        
          by
        
        
          numerous lexical
        
        
          errors.
        
        
          The
        
        
          vocabulary does
        
        
          not correspond to
        
        
          the task.
        
        
          Generally
        
        
          accurate
        
        
          grammatical
        
        
          structures are
        
        
          used
        
        
          Some accurate
        
        
          grammatical
        
        
          structures are
        
        
          used
        
        
          correspond to
        
        
          Limited
        
        
          accurate
        
        
          grammatical
        
        
          structures are
        
        
          used
        
        
          The
        
        
          comprehension
        
        
          of the report is
        
        
          hampered
        
        
          by
        
        
          numerous